Copyrights and disclaimers

All the content of this website is mine and can't be used without written authorization.
This website is private and has no relation with my current employer.
News‎ > ‎

Why OpenStreetMap fails to replace official or proprietary base maps in a sustainable way ?

posted 27 Dec 2011 20:49 by Cédric MOULLET   [ updated 27 Dec 2011 20:55 ]
  1. Because it’s not possible to make a map for all zoom levels
  2. Because the finances are not secured on long term
  3. Because the data model is not defined
  4. Because the precision is heterogeneous
  5. Because the reliability is heterogeneous
  6. Because the completeness is heterogeneous
  7. Because it requires attribution
  8. Because the data are difficult to extract
  9. Because noone takes the responsibility about the data
  10. Because it lacks a QA step by an accountable body
  11. Because it is not multilingual
  12. Because first acquisition is fun and data update is boring
  13. Because Google Map Maker Workflow is for the broad public and OpenStreetMap workflow for the map enthusiasts

Having said that, OpenStreetMap is great for rapid maping, has great examples of local success (Best Of OSM) and can be used in a lot of cases.

Two non representative examples: Le Lieu CH or Ragusa IT